by Dr Marie Segrave
This article introduces The Conversation’s series, State of Imprisonment, which provides snapshots of imprisonment trends in each state and territory. The intention is to provide a basis for informed public discussion of imprisonment policies and of the costs and consequences for Australia of rising rates of incarceration.
Australia has reached a decade-high rate of imprisonment. The Australian Bureau of Statistics’ announcement of this last year created little impact or interest.
Across Australia, 33,791 persons were in adult corrective services custody at June 30 2014. That was a 10% increase from 2013. By the December quarter 2014, the average daily number of prisoners had risen to 34,647.
For both men and women in custody, the most frequent serious offence was an act intended to cause injury (21 per cent for men, 20 per cent for women).
The next most common offences differed according to gender. Men were equally likely to be in custody for a most serious offence of sexual assault, unlawful entry with intent and illicit drug offences (all 12 per cent). For women, the next most likely reasons were illicit drug offences (17 per cent) and offences against justice procedures, government security and operations (11 per cent).
The circumstances that lead to imprisonment and the context of the crime cannot be ascertained from such data. It still raises important questions about the use of imprisonment for non-violent offences.
Indigenous Australians suffer punitive approach
Nationally, the rate of imprisonment for ATSI people was 13 times higher than for non-Indigenous people at June 30, 2014. This figure covers a diverse situation across the nation. In Western Australia, ATSI men and women are 18 times more times likely than non-Indigenous Australians to be imprisoned in WA, whereas in Tasmania the rate is four times higher.
In 2013, Chris Cunneen articulated the concern in The Conversation that:
… too many Indigenous Australians will remain second-class citizens in their own country … remaining the object of law when it comes to criminalisation and incarceration.
The most recent statistics affirm that Cunneen’s predictions are unfolding with little sign of abating.
Prisons are a poor substitute for mental health care
An emerging concern is the recognition and realisation that mental illness and mental impairment are diagnosed at much higher rates within our imprisoned population than in the wider community.
Data on this issue is less easily accessed nationally. What we do know is that there is a “higher incidence of mental health problems in the Australian prison population than in the general population” and that “almost two in five prison entrants (38 per cent) reported having been told that they have a mental health disorder”.
Prison is fast becoming a significant location for individuals with high mental health needs to be supported and managed. This reflects a national malaise, stemming from the responsibility we must all bear for decisions to remove so many of the support networks that were in place decades ago – and to remove them without any replacement or alternative. The result has been the criminalisation of an increasing number of people.
Public debate ignores need for change
This brief review of current data and trends raises several important questions: why is imprisonment being used, for what purpose, and to what ends?
This series aims to offer a snapshot of incarceration trends across Australia and to identify imprisonment policies and practices that we need to change.
Each state and territory has different issues of most concern. These may relate to rates of imprisonment of particular marginalised populations, or legislative changes resulting in remand rates skyrocketing and/or parole being virtually unobtainable.
While Australian trends in imprisonment can always be favourably compared to other nations such as the US, it is clear that current trends across the nation have significant short-and long-term consequences. Attracting public attention and engagement with these consequences is challenging in a political, social, and media environmentdominated by law-and-order politics.
This series aims to provide a platform for public discussion via a critical mass of articles that take stock of the situation in each state and territory, and as a nation.
Dr Marie Segrave is a senior lecturer of criminology in the School of Social Sciences at Monash University.
This article has previously appeared on The Conversation
Study Criminology at Monash
State of imprisonment: Victoria is leading the nation backwards
by Dr Marie Segrave, Dr Anna Eriksson and Emma Russell This article is part of The Conversation’s series, State … Continue reading State of imprisonment: Victoria is leading the nation backwards
Emotional Experiences of early parenthood project
A new online resource supporting Australian families in early parenthood produced by The Health in … Continue reading Emotional Experiences of early parenthood project
SoSS academics draft working paper on ‘Women in Politics’
Monash Academics from the School of Social Sciences, Professor Jacqui True, Dr Swati Parashar and … Continue reading SoSS academics draft working paper on ‘Women in Politics’
SoSS awards a number of prizes at the end of each year for the highest … Continue reading Honours Prizes
Congratulations to our SoSS Honours Award Recipients
On Monday 8 December, the SoSS team held a morning tea to recognise the recipients … Continue reading Congratulations to our SoSS Honours Award Recipients
From intern to “in government”: Premier-elect a former Monash Politics student
Victoria’s Premier-elect, Daniel Andrews, is yet another graduate of the Monash Politics program to be … Continue reading From intern to “in government”: Premier-elect a former Monash Politics student
A space for feminist international relations: Professor Ann Tickner visits Monash
This month, Monash is hosting distinguished International Relations academic, Professor Ann Tickner. Professor Tickner said … Continue reading A space for feminist international relations: Professor Ann Tickner visits Monash
Greg Barton: Challenges Posed by the Islamic State Movement at Home and Abroad
Greg Barton, Professor of Indonesian Studies and Director of the Centre for Islam and the Modern … Continue reading Greg Barton: Challenges Posed by the Islamic State Movement at Home and Abroad
Policy Impact: Jo Lindsay contributes to work and care policy
The honourable Jenny Macklin MP invited Jo Lindsay to participate in a policy development Roundtable … Continue reading Policy Impact: Jo Lindsay contributes to work and care policy
What Can New Zealand Do on the United Nations Security Council to Advance the Women, Peace and Security Agenda?
This post first appeared on the Women, Peace and Security Academic Collective blog. The Women, … Continue reading What Can New Zealand Do on the United Nations Security Council to Advance the Women, Peace and Security Agenda?
Celebrating 25 Years of the Parliamentary Internship Program
The Parliament of Victoria is proud to mark the 25th Anniversary of the Victorian Parliamentary Internship program next year…
Social Sciences Research Strength in the School of Social Sciences: Our Future Fellows
The School of Social Sciences (SoSS), led by Professor Sharon Pickering, now houses six Social Sciences … Continue reading Social Sciences Research Strength in the School of Social Sciences: Our Future Fellows