Defensive homicide applies to killers who unreasonably believed their actions were necessary to defend themselves or others; many are women who are victims of family violence.
The study, by researchers from Monash University and Domestic Violence Resource Centre Victoria, examined eight cases of women charged with killing their partners since defensive homicide was introduced by the former Labor government in 2005. The study found family violence was still poorly understood and the perception of what is ‘reasonable’ self-defence continues to be shaped by gender-based stereotypes.
Monash University criminology expert Dr Danielle Tyson from the School of Political and Social Inquiry said there still remained a failure to understand how prior family violence may affect women’s responses and why victims may remain in abusive relationships.
“If defensive homicide is abolished and no other partial defence is established to replace it, it is likely that some women who kill in the context of family violence will receive harsher sentences than is currently the case,” Dr Tyson said.
“The current limited recognition of family violence gives us little confidence that women will successfully be able to claim self-defence at trial.”
Dr Tyson said the need for law reform to ensure justice for women who kill violent partners has been well established for some decades.
“Currently defensive homicide is being used more often by men who kill other men and rarely by women, but the reliance on partial defences or manslaughter by men who kill other men is nothing new and not a sound reason to abolish defensive homicide,” Dr Tyson said.
“Victoria has led the way for other Australian jurisdictions in its commitment to bringing about more positive changes for women defendants.
“We need to continue our efforts to develop the law in a way that adequately recognises the impact of family violence on women’s lives, but also to work with the legal profession to improve the applications of the law so that the spirit and potential of legislative reform can be effectively realised.”
Dr Tyson said that until women victims of family violence can be seen to be successfully raising self-defence, defensive homicide should not be abolished.
“We need to see further shifts in the legal profession and culture around the recognition of family violence and women’s responses to it. At present, there is no evidence that women’s prospects of raising self-defence successfully have improved,” Dr Tyson said.
“There is still a long way to go to improve legal responses for women who kill an abusive partner and this won’t be achieved if the current laws are abolished.”
Find out more:
- School of Political and Social Inquiry
- The Centre for Women’s Studies and Gender Research (CWSGR)
New report on legal responses to intimate partner homicide
Dr Debbie Kirkwood and Dr Danielle Tyson, both research fellows in Criminology in the School … Continue reading New report on legal responses to intimate partner homicide
Survey to shape Victoria’s response to family violence
Monash University is urging professionals across the state to help shape the way Victoria responds … Continue reading Survey to shape Victoria’s response to family violence
Criminology Public Panel: New and Persistent Challenges in Sexual Violence
On Wednesday 6 April 2016, the Monash Criminological Horizons Annual Public Lecture was held at … Continue reading Criminology Public Panel: New and Persistent Challenges in Sexual Violence
New Report on Restrictive and Coercive Interventions in Disability and Mental Health Care
Monash criminologist, Dr Claire Spivakovsky has released a short Reportdetailing findings from a state-wide consultation … Continue reading New Report on Restrictive and Coercive Interventions in Disability and Mental Health Care
Homicide, Gender and Responsibility Edited Collection published
Monash criminologists Dr Kate Fitz-Gibbon and Professor Sandra Walklate have edited a new book examining … Continue reading Homicide, Gender and Responsibility Edited Collection published
Victorian Royal Commission into Family Violence Report
Royal Commission calls for complete overhaul of Victoria’s family violence services and responses Monash Criminologist Dr … Continue reading Victorian Royal Commission into Family Violence Report
‘Silent victims’: royal commission recommends better protections for child victims of family violence
By Kate Fitz-Gibbon, Monash University and Wendy O’Brien, Deakin University Among the Victorian Royal Commission into Family Violence’s most … Continue reading ‘Silent victims’: royal commission recommends better protections for child victims of family violence
Royal commission calls for complete overhaul of Victoria’s family violence services and responses
Kate Fitz-Gibbon, Monash University The Royal Commission into Family Violence’s final report, containing 227 recommendations, … Continue reading Royal commission calls for complete overhaul of Victoria’s family violence services and responses
New book published by Border Crossing Observatory Team
A team of researchers from the Border Crossing Observatory has co-authored a new book that … Continue reading New book published by Border Crossing Observatory Team
Monash Filicide Research in The Age
In the wake of several high profile murders of children by their parents, Monash filicide … Continue reading Monash Filicide Research in The Age
RSVP Now for the Monash Criminological Horizons Annual Lecture
Sexual violence and exploitation is a significant and serious ongoing social problem. With the evolution … Continue reading RSVP Now for the Monash Criminological Horizons Annual Lecture
Dr Asher Flynn co-edits International Journal of Crime, Justice and Social Democracy Special Issue on Critical Criminology
To highlight the importance of critical criminology discussions in addressing some of the most important social, legal … Continue reading Dr Asher Flynn co-edits International Journal of Crime, Justice and Social Democracy Special Issue on Critical Criminology