by Justin O’Connor
A column of light shines from Hobart’s Queen’s Domain, where Japanese artist Ryoji Ikeda’s Spectra reaches up to the looming clouds, visible across the city. The normally empty streets are crowded, the ever more posh restaurants full, as theDark MOFO festival – the evil twin of high summer’s MONA FOMA (Museum of Old and New Art’s Festival Of Music and Art) – takes centre stage. Ten days of music, performance, film, visual art and food has transformed Hobart’s winter season.
The festival is part of a wider transformation brought on by the arrival of MONA – Museum of Old and New Arts – into the suburban, working class city of Glenorchy in early 2011. Taxi drivers are enthused by the surge in visitors – though there are still too many taxis, apparently.
Senior state politicians talk about a new golden age. Officials trumpet the 40 per cent rise in flights to Hobart in the last year. Local hipsters are savouring the chance to roll their eyes at the “Melbourne types” who now clog up all the venues. Chance conversations in pubs, hotels and shops suggest a new sense of excitement for the future.
The man behind the movement
Hobart was never a blank canvas yet everybody understands who is responsible for the new Hobart – the new Tasmania, even: David Walsh. The gambling millionaire and accidental art collector is a local legend.
Born and raised in Glenorchy, Walsh took on the art world: including that mix of artists, po-faced academics, bespectacled art critics, and the moneyed men and women who bid by telephone – and won.
MONA, a A$75 million building sunk deep into the rock, is less iconic ‘starchitecture’ and more Delphic shrine. Its front entrance is on the Derwent River, and best approached via the newly-commissioned MONA ferry. It is currently by far the most exciting museum in Australia. Locals gleefully pronounce that they have leapfrogged Melbourne into the global art league.
MONA is an events brand, a music festival, a tourist experience, a placemaker and, with the Hobart waterfront set to be re-developed, potentially an urban developer. But at its heart is the museum.
The buzzwords used to describe it are: fun, democratic, accessible and risk-taking, all of which are frequently deemed to be absent from publicly run museums. These choice words are elitist and serve to avoid politicians offending the taxpayers.
The second thing you will learn about MONA (after David Walsh) is that there are no labels on the walls. There is a sort of iPhone device (the “O system”) with headphone and bluetooth which can tell you about the art, but only if you want it to. You can also vote like/hate on each artwork and retrieve your tour at leisure via internet.
Dark MOFO coincided with the opening of a new exhibition, The Red Queen. The bright crimson, underpinning the whole Dark MOFO brand, lit up hotels and restaurants throughout the duration of the festival.
The Red Queen exhibition
The Red Queen (taken from author Lewis Carroll’s book Through the Looking Glass) is a concept in evolutionary biology in which every competitive innovation is eventually cancelled out by everything else catching up.
In Carroll’s book, Alice asks why when they run the landscape never seems to move. The exhibitions’ anti-heroine says: “now, here, you see, it takes all the running you can do to keep in the same place”. The exhibition’s website then tells us:
We like to imagine we are struggling ever-forward to some end-point – personal, collective, universal – that will atone for our suffering and make our joys mean something. Evolution has no such agenda, nothing in mind for us, as it molds us to the shape of our environment.
When you look at it like this, and surrender the assumption of progress, all of a sudden our words and deeds – like the Red Queen’s – mean nothing and everything at once; rich and strange nonsense indeed.” The exhibition addresses the question: “how does art fit into this”?
It is hard to see this as “fun”, in the usual sense of the family friendly, uncontroversial art exhibition that one might find in Brisbane’s Gallery of Modern Art (GOMA), for example.
What is striking is that the art – its difficult, multiple meanings, its unpredictable effects and affects – is taken deadly seriously. Democratic access is not achieved by making it look like a department store or a bad version of Disneyland. Instead its success is in the belief that everybody can have a response to art at the deepest level – should they want to. It does not lack pedagogy but condescension.
This is MONA’s risk-taking – the belief that the public is made up of grown-ups. It is this, not the money or the glamour, which lies at the heart of its success. It is this that will be the hardest to hold onto if it simply becomes part of a regeneration machine.
The caricature of the public museum as elitist and boring is not promoted by MONA but by the public sector itself. It forms part of that collective loss of nerve, or loss of mission, that once animated the great public museum. MONA is too often pointed to as an example of why a public museum cannot be relevant. Instead, it should be a lesson of how it can become so.
If the great and risky splash that is MONA is not to become yet another ripple of art-led urban regeneration (read: real estate) then this lesson needs to be learned, not just for the museum but for the wider purpose of art and culture in Australian society.
Professor Justin O’Connor works in the School of English, Communications and Performance Studies at Monash University.
This article as appeared previously in The Conversation.
Journalism Futures: New York Field School
Following a dramatic year in American politics, and the claims and counter-claims of ‘fake news’, … Continue reading Journalism Futures: New York Field School
Celebrating student achievements at the Monash Arts Awards
This May the Monash Arts Awards celebrated the outstanding academic achievements of its students over two … Continue reading Celebrating student achievements at the Monash Arts Awards
Creative city, smart city … whose city is it?
In 2007 US creative cities “guru” Richard Florida was flown to Noosa to tell the … Continue reading Creative city, smart city … whose city is it?
Martyr and Conviction Politics
Two major projects, Martyr and Conviction Politics, will shed new light on the activism by … Continue reading Martyr and Conviction Politics
Christiane Barro & alum Danny Tran shortlisted for Walkley Award
Monash University journalism student Christiane Barro has been shortlisted for the Walkley Award for Student Journalist of the Year. And in the Young Walkley’s Community/Regional Journalism category, Monash alumnus and ABC journalist Danny Tran was named a finalist for his work on the Catholic child abuse scandals has attracted national attention.
SOPHIS’ annual lecture with Prof Julian Savulescu
‘What’s the cause of climate change? Standard answer: carbon emissions. What’s the cause of terror? Standard … Continue reading SOPHIS’ annual lecture with Prof Julian Savulescu
Going back to school for cross-platform skills
Seven years into an established career as a radio journalist for SBS, Peggy Giakoumelos went back to school with Monash.
Journalism alum Alysia Thomas-Sam now Chief-of-Staff at Nine News
Assistant Chief of Staff at Nine News, Alysia Thomas-Sam has valuable advice to offer people starting out in their journalism careers: don’t be scared to make mistakes, and be yourself.
Top media editors explain why journalism is important
Earlier this year I filmed a number of interviews with senior media editors and I asked them what they believed was the point of journalism today. Are journalists still the watchdogs of society? And if so, how should they engage better with their audiences in order to improve the tasks of investigation, interpretation and dissemination?
Broadcaster, Waleed Aly, receives PhD from Monash University
Malthouse opportunities and new Australian musicals at Monash
The Monash Centre for Theatre and Performance (CTP) has great opportunities for students to further … Continue reading Malthouse opportunities and new Australian musicals at Monash
Tom Doig aims for new heights in Canada
Monash University PhD candidate and author Tom Doig has been offered a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to study with renowned scholar Naomi Klein at The Banff Centre for Arts and Creativity’s writing residency in Canada.
Tom, who has already published a book during his PhD candidature, shares some insight into his marathon post-graduate journey.