Gina Rinehart’s father Lang Hancock was a big proponent of Western Australia seceding from the Australian federation, and every time the latest figures on GST distributions are released,sympathetic sentiments come blowing east across the Nullabor. But could Western Australia, or any state for that matter, actually declare independence and leave? While the Australian Constitution allows for an increase in the number of member states of the federation, it makes no provision for existing states to secede from the union.
Secession refers to an act by a political community to withdraw from the jurisdiction of a larger entity of which it is a constituent member. It is, in essence, an action intended to result in full self-government.
The demand to secede generally has one of two objectives at its core. Secession may be an end in itself in which case the protagonists are desirous to dissolve the union, or some aspect of it, in its present form. In other cases, secessionist claims constitute part of a strategic bargaining process to force the central government (or their counterparts) to take their concerns seriously.
The preamble of the Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act makes clear that the original states are united in an indissoluble union.
John Quick and Robert Garran, who wrote the annotated Constitution, argued that the framers inserted a reference to the indissolubility of the federation as a reminder that the union established under the new Act should not be undone by the people.
In spite of the political jostling that takes place between state premiers and the Commonwealth, the Australian federation has been a stable institution. Only Western Australia has seriously pursued the secession option. Its most famous attempt to exit the federation occurred in 1933 when, following a successful referendum of its people, the WA government presented a petition to secede to the Imperial parliament.
The British rejected the application on the grounds that it would only entertain a request to alter the Constitution on instruction of the Commonwealth parliament.
But is the federation a perpetual union from which no state could conceivably secede?
There are two potential avenues available to an Australian state intent on such a course of action, although both options are contested by legal scholars to a greater or lesser extent.
The first of these is that a state could petition the Commonwealth parliament to hold a referendum pursuant to section 128 of the Constitution. Assuming federal parliament was willing to oblige such a request, the proposal would then have to be assented to by a majority of the Australian population along with the majority of the states.
The second option would be for a state to secede unilaterally. This would entail an Australian state passing an Act of its own parliament declaring its withdrawal from the federation and asserting its status as a fully sovereign nation. Such an action is regarded by many legal scholars as unlawful.
Notwithstanding the constitutionality or otherwise of unilateral secession, such a course of action is possible in practice. A state could only be prevented from pursuing this option if the Commonwealth was prepared to use the military to force the seceding state to remain in the federation against its will. The scenario of the Commonwealth invading a state seems preposterous, although cannot be entirely dismissed.
In the end, the legalities of dissolving the federation are nothing compared to the logistics of an Australian state opting for full independence.
Federations allow smaller sovereign units to share the burden of some of the more onerous costs associated with running and maintaining the territory under its control. For any of the states to become fully self-supporting on terms that local populations are presently accustomed would be difficult, given the size of the territories that states’ administer and their diminutive local populations.
It would be a challenge for any existing state to acquire all of the trappings associated with nationhood. The new nation would have to establish its own military, police its own borders, print its own currency and issue its own passports. It would be required to radically extend its bureaucratic apparatus, particularly in respect to revenue and taxation collection. It would also have to forge its own diplomatic ties and treaties with other sovereign nations, including with the federation from which it had withdrawn.
Even the serial secessionist of the federation, Western Australia, does not have the stomach to pursue full self determination. Even at the height of WA’s recent discontent over the mining tax, the state’s premier Colin Barnett positively rejected any suggestion that WA had any intention of seceding from the federation.
But does this mean necessarily that it is futile for a state to talk of secession?
Campbell Sharman, a political scientist formerly based at the University of Western Australia, has argued that:
…thinking about the justifications for secession forces us to realise where our system of government is defective and needs repairing.
As the federation continues to be eroded in ways that further undermine the autonomy of the states, the threat of secession serves as a reminder to central government that the states harbour genuine grievances that need urgent and serious attention. This article originally appeared on The Conversation.
Dr Narelle Miragliotta is a Lecturer in the School of Political and Social Inquiry at Monash University.
Updates from COP21: Marketing the climate summit by ‘greening’ the Eiffel Tower
Dr David Holmes, senior lecturer in Communications and Media Studies at Monash, is in France for the Paris Climate Summit and will be reporting regularly on the events.
Monash supports marriage equality
Monash has joined over 690 organisations and numerous Australian individuals showing their support through Australian Marriage Equality.
Consuming Anzac: some thoughts on the Anzac centenary
If prizes were given out for the enthusiasm with which nations commemorate the centenary of the Great War, Australia would be first by a long shot. Dr Carolyn Holbrook looks at ‘Brandzac’.
From hostility to lasting friendship: cultural reflections from Turkish and Anzac soldiers
For the first time in Australia, stories of Turkish soldiers will be told alongside those of Anzac soldiers in a bilingual exhibition at Monash Univeristy about the Gallipoli experience. The exhibition has been curated by Dr Azer Banu Kemaloğlu, of Canakkale Onsekiz Mart University.
On remembering and forgetting war
Join us this Remembrance Day for the launch of – World War One: A History in 100 Stories – a path-breaking social history written by Monash historians Professor Bruce Scates, Rebecca Wheatley and Laura James.
Monash project on Women, Peace & Security makes its way to United Nations Security Council
Australian ambassador, H. E. Gillian Bird, made in her statement to the United Nations Security Council yesterday during the annual debate on Women Peace and Security.
From pages to the silver screen: Death or Liberty documentary launched in October
A feature length documentary film adaptation of Dr Tony Moore’s book Death or Liberty, detailing the lives of rebels and radicals transported to Australia as political prisoners, will have its world premier in Victoria this month, ahead of screenings around Australia and Britain.
Godzilla, Wine and Video Games: Getting to know Monash researcher Jason Christopher Jones
Want to know how the Japanese language, wine, Godzilla and video games all tie in to being a researcher at Monash? Lecturer in Japanese studies, Jason Jones, tells us about his passion for ‘all things Japanese’, and about his research around the themes of cultural exchange and adaptation.
Telling the larger story about terrorism: a conversation with PhD candidate Noor Huda Ismail
PhD candidate Noor Huda Ismail is an author, filmmaker, activist, and self-described “repentant journalist”, and has a desire to tell a larger story about terrorism, foreign fighters and why people join violent organisations.
Mentoring matters: Global mentors for Monash University students
The value of a mentor both personally and professionally – to provide guidance, support and advice – is almost universal.
In the aid and development sector…
Welcome to Nowhere: Monash at the Fringe Festival
The Melbourne Fringe festival is providing plenty of opportunities for Monash to showcase its theatre outputs this year.
Indian dignitaries visit the Faculty of Arts
On 26 August, the Faculty of Arts had the honour of welcoming a His Excellency, Navdeep Suri, the High Commissioner of India in Australia…