By Dr Andrea Baker
The imprisonment of the Australian journalist Peter Greste in Egypt received news attention worldwide.
The court case was complex and multifaceted and riddled by unsubstantiated evidence, contradictory testimonies and procedural irregularities. As a result, it proved to be a difficult case to report on by three major media outlets such as Al Jazeera English, the BBC and the ABC.
Their news coverage was reduced to a Western versus Egyptian view, according to a new study, with less than half the reportage focused on the allegations against the three journalists
As a former ABC and BBC journalist, Greste, along with Egyptian-Canadian national, Mohamed Fahmy, and Egyptian, Baher Mohamed was working for Al Jazeera English when they were arrested by Egyptian authorities on 29 December 2013 for allegedly producing false news that was detrimental to the country’s transition to a democracy.
The trio were also accused of associating with the Muslim Brotherhood, Egypt’s oldest and largest Islamist organisation, which had been blacklisted as a terrorist group since late December 2013.
The long trial concluded on 23 June 2014 and the journalists were sentenced to seven years (Greste and Fahmy) and 10years (Mohamed) in jail in Egypt.
This case marked the first time a Western journalist (such as Greste) had been imprisoned due to terrorism-related offences in Egypt, amid fears of a frenzied press freedom crackdown by military authorities afterthe Arab Spring of 2011.
Journalism academic Dr Andrea Baker from Monash University’s School of Media, Film and Journalism analysed the coverage of the trial by Al Jazeera English, the BBC and the ABC from the day of the arrest (29 December 2013) until a week after their final sentencing (30 June 2014).
“The networks were chosen because they were credible, public broadcasters, Greste has worked at all three; and it would be insightful to examine how the outlets reported on a court case of their employees, both past and present,” Dr Baker said.
Of the 294 articles analysed, 40 per cent of the stories came from Al Jazeera English, 38 per cent from the ABC; and 22 per cent from the BBC.
Proportionately, 70 per cent of the AJE stories focused on the innocent victims’ news narrative; 60 per cent of the ABC reports centred onGreste and his family, and60 per cent of the BBC coverage concentrating onpress freedom issues.
The findings also highlight how parochial the Australian media are, with 55 per cent of the ABC’s coverage focused on Peter Greste while the other two broadcasters focused on all three journalists.
Dr Baker said the findings suggested the media outlets had allowed a Western bias by focusing on innocent victim, family or freedom of the press angles while downplaying the Egyptian point of view.
The complete outcomes of this research is published in a monograph titled, The best things in life are free (The case of Peter Greste and notions of press freedom) for the upcoming Australian Journalism Monograph, 2015 Volume 15, Issue 1, (which is published by the Griffith Centre for Cultural Research, Griffith University, QLD, in association with the Journalism Education and Research Association of Australia).
Find out more:
Simons, Jarvis shortlisted for Amnesty media award
Monash University journalism’s Associate Professor Margaret Simons and senior lecturer Heather Jarvis have been named finalists in the Amnesty International 2017 Media Awards.
Global Correspondent unit launches in Europe
Take two groups of students at universities situated at the opposite side of the globe, put them at Monash Prato in northern Italy and mix in a few days at EU institutions in Brussels and you get Global Correspondent.
Not jobs and growth but post-capitalism
The term “creative industries” was first applied to the cultural sector by UK New Labour in 1998, … Continue reading Not jobs and growth but post-capitalism
Simons shares wisdom with journalism students
Award-winning journalist, author and academic Margaret Simons recently joined the journalism department in Monash University’s … Continue reading Simons shares wisdom with journalism students
Christiane Barro wins Walkley for Student of the Year
Monash journalism student Christiane Barro won the Walkley Award for student journalist of the year in Sydney last night.
Calla unafraid of challenging storytelling
For Calla Wahlquist, after giving up on becoming a vet it was working as a … Continue reading Calla unafraid of challenging storytelling
Journalism academics engage with Senate Committee
Dr Colleen Murrell from Journalism (MFJ), gave testimony on 11 July before the ‘Senate Select … Continue reading Journalism academics engage with Senate Committee
From screen to sound for Hayley
After completing her Honours in Film and TV studies at Monash, career success for Hayley … Continue reading From screen to sound for Hayley
Curiosity and critical thinking propels Anders’ career
For Anders Furze, studies in Film and TV has led to varied career outcomes. But … Continue reading Curiosity and critical thinking propels Anders’ career
John settles into a career behind the camera
For John Holdsworth, a clear vision of what he wants to achieve has led to … Continue reading John settles into a career behind the camera
Monash gives Alasdair access to industry
For Alasdair Mulligan having access to Monash tutors and lecturers active within the journalism industry … Continue reading Monash gives Alasdair access to industry
Smethurst wins Press Gallery Journalist of the Year
News Corp national political editor (Sunday editions) and Monash University alumna Annika Smethurst has won the 2017 Press Gallery Journalist of the Year.