The democratising potential of social media have long been heralded. Successive government ministers, starting with Helen Coonan, Stephen Conroy and now Malcolm Turnbull, have all talked up the marvels of “user-generated” media where everyone can have a say and produce their own content.
But the next time you hear some version of “we are relaxing the laws around media ownership in this country because we are living in a world of citizen journalists and so many sources of information and entertainment that makes the old laws redundant”, think again.
Can’t stop clicking
A new study conducted at Monash University entitled “Facebook, disenchantment and deactivation: The views of young Australian university students”, the findings of which are yet to be published, has found that the opposite is true. The Honours research has found that the main way people interact with Facebook – which has the largest user base of any social media in Australia – is for “validation”.
Very little new content is produced, and less information gained, other than a kind of online small talk. Where information is received it is through media sharing of content produced by the mainstream media that governments seem so keen on deregulating.
The study included a two week survey of 560 respondents conducted in July this year, of which 83% were studying at a university. Three-quarters of those studying said they checked Facebook more than five times a day.
Of the students at the high end of Facebook checking, many felt it to be an unhealthy addiction. One student reported checking their Facebook account ten times an hour, 18 hours a day.
The more addictive behaviour was attributed to the Facebook mobile app, which enabled continual short bursts of updates all day.
And participants reported that when they did check Facebook, they were just passively skimming through content at a very superficial level. This is particularly interesting in terms of the claim that Web 2.0 is a form of “produserly” media, where everyone is producing their own content.
The term “produsage” was popularised by Axel Bruns and Jan-Hinrik Schmidt, when they described the way new web environments let people switch between using existing content and producing alterations and extensions.
A key element of Bruns and Schmidt’s argument, as well as that of Claudia Grinnell, is that it assumes a high level of active engagement from the user. However, participants in this study described the opposite phenomena.
Despite compulsive account checking, in some cases up to almost two hundred times per day, participants described an increasing lack of active participation.
In some cases participants were even judgemental of those who were highly active or seen as contributing too much content. This suggest a shift in usage practices where users have lost the inclination to actively contribute and produce their own content.
Steve Rubel, an executive at one of the world’s largest public relations firms Edelman, argues that we are entering the third age of the internet, which is one of “validation”.
When social networking began to escalate there was a ‘friend-ing’ arms race, where everyone tried to accumulate as many friends as possible. This devalued the idea of online friendship.
Now, Rubel says, that we are living in an age where there is “too much content and not enough time”.
The “internet generation” is spread wide and thin, as access to vast networks is reduced to a few clicks.
The rapid uptake of social media has brought on an overload of access to both information and people, forcing users to make more critical judgements when operating online.
People are no longer actively engaged with mundane content produced by their “friends” online. Instead, Rubel explains that in the age of “validation”, the “academic or expert is highly trusted” as “people want to know people who know their stuff”.
Perhaps the need for validation is an attempt to cut through the overwhelming feed of clutter which permeates our increasingly mediated daily lives, if not just our news feed.
This article first appeared in The Conversation
Back to school for Peggy
Seven years into an established career as a radio journalist for SBS, Peggy Giakoumelos went back … Continue reading Back to school for Peggy
Alysia not scared to make mistakes
Alysia Thomas-Sam has some valuable advice to offer people starting out in their journalism careers: … Continue reading Alysia not scared to make mistakes
Top media editors explain why journalism is important
Earlier this year Dr Colleen Murrell filmed a number of interviews with senior media editors and she asked them what they believed was the point of journalism today.
Legacies of resistance we need to act upon
PhD candidate Matteo Dutto shares his PhD research into three iconic legacies of resistance in Australia.
Nicola not immune from pull of journalism
Despite planning to be a research scientist, Nicola McCaskill has instead leapt into a career … Continue reading Nicola not immune from pull of journalism
Mairéad’s career progression ‘on steroids’
According to Mairéad Bilton-Gough, once you get your first break in the media industry your career … Continue reading Mairéad’s career progression ‘on steroids’
Is Melbourne the music capital of Australia?
By Andrea Baker Melbourne’s successful bid to host a prestigious international conference on music cities … Continue reading Is Melbourne the music capital of Australia?
Sumeyya Ilanbey named a finalist in the CNA Awards
Master of Journalism student Sumeyya Ilanbey has been named a finalist in the Community Newspapers of Australia (CNA) awards.
Can 36 questions make any two people fall in love?
Three Monash University students decided to see what would happen if they each went up to a stranger and asked if they could share two hours and 36 of the most intimate questions imaginable – and let them record it for publication.
Stephanie Brookes launches groundbreaking book
Monash University journalism lecturer Dr Stephanie Brookes has published a groundbreaking book, Politics, Media and Campaign … Continue reading Stephanie Brookes launches groundbreaking book
Alison Stieven-Taylor moderates debate in Sydney
Sydney’s annual Head On Photo Festival invited Monash PhD candidate Alison Stieven-Taylor to moderate the … Continue reading Alison Stieven-Taylor moderates debate in Sydney
Zain has the Walkleys in his sights
As an international student new to Australia, Zain Nabi only had limited knowledge of the … Continue reading Zain has the Walkleys in his sights