Tony Abbott’s 2013 election platform promised to “restore accountability and improve transparency measures to be more accountable to you”.
In spite of this promise the first Abbott government budget will see the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (OAIC) closed, and its functions assigned to other government agencies.
This back-to-the-future move is likely to make it harder and probably more expensive for long suffering FOI users.
The OAIC was formed in 2010 as part of the reforms of the federal FOI law, which sought to address long turn-around times and an expensive appeal system for rejected FOI requests that had rendered the first 1982 law close to useless.
The OIAC brought together the privacy and Freedom of Information (FOI) commissioners, allowing appeals on rejected requests to be made directly to the FOI commissioner. This proved a much cheaper process than the old system of having the appeals dealt with by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). Had the OAIC been properly staffed and funded it would most likely also helped improve turnaround times compared to the AAT.
From the budget statement, it’s clear the FOI review function will be transferred back to the AAT from 2015. Funding for the AAT will be beefed up with some of the $35 million in savings (over five years) delivered as a result of the restructure. The Abbott government claims this will make the FOI appeals process more effective.
A step backwards
In reality the budget has returned much of the federal access to information system to its dysfunctional pre-2010 state. The cost to appeal a FOI decision could increase significantly. The fee to lodge an appeal with the AAT is currently A$816. Some of the FOI reviews could be exempt from the fee and part of the cost will be refundable if you win the appeal, but in most cases the fee will increase. Add to this the cost of legal representation needed before the AAT and most FOI applicants will probably think twice before they appeal.
The Attorney-General’s department will from 2015 be responsible for overseeing the Freedom of Information Act and issuing FOI guidelines. In essence Attorney General George Brandis will be expected to drive the decades-long effort to change the culture of secrecy to one of openness and facilitation of access to information. Based on Brandis’ weak interest in the Open Government Partnership there are reasons for concern regarding this culture change aim.
What the research tells us
Preliminary findings in my research project comparing the first generation Victorian FOI law with the reformed Commonwealth law shows the federal law provides quicker and easier access to information.
In the project six members of the public were asked to seek the expense accounts (including details of travel and work dinners) of six Victorian state ministers and their federal counterparts. For all the federal ministers the information was found and downloaded within hours without submitting formal FOI requests. In Victoria FOI process, while the requests were submitted in most cases, the information was not obtained.
The federal reforms were overseen and to a large extent driven by the OAIC. The question is, will Attorney General George Brandis carry on the work of the OAIC? Openness, transparency and accountability is easy to promise when in opposition, but hard to deliver in government. This is why the Open Government Partnership is so important.
The starving of the Commonwealth FOI system in this federal budget will most likely make it harder for long suffering FOI users. This is a great pity. A well functioning FOI system creates a win-win situation. It encourages public participation in the political process and it builds trust between governments and citizens via true openness and transparency.
It is hard to see how the slashing of the OAIC will deliver on the Abbott election promise of increased government accountability. Perhaps this should be added to the growing list of “please explains” that the first Abbott/Hockey budget has created.
This article first appeared on The Conversation.
Getting to know … Phil Chubb
Monash Head of Journalism Associate Professor Phil Chubb says the best thing about his role … Continue reading Getting to know … Phil Chubb
Hannah, Kate named Walkley scholarship finalists
Monash University journalism students Hannah Scholte and Kate Wong Hoy have been named finalists for the 2015 Jacoby-Walkley Scholarship.
Dani wins the Herb Thomas Memorial Trust award
Dani Rothwell has won the Herb Thomas Memorial Trust award as the most outstanding journalism … Continue reading Dani wins the Herb Thomas Memorial Trust award
Getting to know … Dr Andrea Baker
Monash journalism senior lecturer Dr Andrea Baker shares her latest research projects, her favourite places and a pearl of wisdom.
The Peter Greste case & notions of press freedom
The imprisonment of the Australian journalist Peter Greste in Egypt received news attention worldwide.
Alana and Naomi are finalists in the Young Walkleys
Monash University journalism alumnae Alana Mitchelson and Naomi Selvaratnam have been named finalists in the Young Walkley Awards to be held in Sydney on July 29.
Jenan Taylor awarded the Guy Morrison Prize
Monash University’s Jenan Taylor has earned national recognition for her unique pauper story, winning the Guy Morrison … Continue reading Jenan Taylor awarded the Guy Morrison Prize
Students retrace historic footsteps of the Great War
Monash journalism students have produced historically significant work in News Corp publications to mark the centenary … Continue reading Students retrace historic footsteps of the Great War
How Hackett made it back to championship swimming
By Julie Tullberg Grant Hackett’s foundation training for the 1,500m freestyle event, which started more … Continue reading How Hackett made it back to championship swimming
Monash graduates make their mark at News Corp
Monash journalism graduates are scoring key roles and winning awards at News Corp publications, particularly the … Continue reading Monash graduates make their mark at News Corp
Endurance: Australian Stories of Drought
Journalism lecturer Dr Deb Anderson has published a fascinating collection of oral histories in her … Continue reading Endurance: Australian Stories of Drought
Jenan Taylor wins Student Journalist of the Year
Monash University’s Jenan Taylor has won the Melbourne Press Club’s 2014 Student Journalist of the … Continue reading Jenan Taylor wins Student Journalist of the Year