Criminology researcher, Dr Danielle Tyson, examines the controversial partial defence of provocation in her new book, Sex, Culpability and the Defence of Provocation (Routledge, 2013).
The partial defence of provocation is one of the most controversial doctrines within the criminal law. It has long been said to operate as a classic apology for male violence against women, and other men. In response to criticisms of provocation, it has now been abolished in a number of international jurisdictions. Addressing the trajectory of debates about reform of the provocation defence across different jurisdictions, Sex, Culpability and the Defence of Provocation is one of the first to analyse provocation cases. In the book, Dr Tyson shows how in such cases the defendant attempts to shift part of the blame onto the victim by relying on a variety of stock stories, such as the nagging woman, the unfaithful or departing wife, or a woman who impugns his masculinity. She analyses law as essentially a storytelling enterprise arguing that while we don’t see or read of the nagging woman per se in contemporary cases, and women aren’t called scolds anymore, through their narratives, defence attorneys continue to evoke these stereotypes. The book discusses how defence narratives also draw on key plots, such as the ‘romance-gone-wrong’, the ‘love-hate relationship’ and the ‘love-triangle’, to solicit sympathy from judges and juries. Now that provocation is gone, Dr Tyson argues, it is time to tell a different story. This is to be achieved by bringing the woman’s voice back into the courtroom drama. If we are to put an end to the injustice of provocation’s victim-blaming narratives, we need to see more prosecuting counsel and judges actively resisting these damaging court narratives. This entails telling a different story, one that explicitly condemns the murderous rage of the cuckolded defendant, emphasises the context of separation and affirms every woman’s right to exercise her independence, autonomy and right to leave a relationship.
A powerful idea, long overdue
Associate Professor Leanne Weber has just published a new collection in the Routledge Rethinking Globalizations … Continue reading A powerful idea, long overdue
Human Trafficking edited collection published
Marie Segrave’s edited collection, Human Trafficking (Ashgate) has just been published. It is one of … Continue reading Human Trafficking edited collection published
Racialized Correctional Governance: The Mutual Constructions of Race and Criminal Justice by Claire Spivakovsky
Dr Claire Spivakovsky joined the School of Political and Social Inquiry as a Lecturer in … Continue reading Racialized Correctional Governance: The Mutual Constructions of Race and Criminal Justice by Claire Spivakovsky
A Second Chance for Justice: The Prosecutions of Gabe Watson for the Death of Tina Thomas by Dr Asher Flynn and Dr Kate Fitz-Gibbon
A Second Chance for Justice critically examines the legal responses to the death of Tina … Continue reading A Second Chance for Justice: The Prosecutions of Gabe Watson for the Death of Tina Thomas by Dr Asher Flynn and Dr Kate Fitz-Gibbon
Contrasts in Punishment: An Explanation of Anglophone Excess and Nordic Exceptionalism by Professor John Pratt and Dr Anna Eriksson
Why do some modern societies punish their offenders differently to others? Why are some more … Continue reading Contrasts in Punishment: An Explanation of Anglophone Excess and Nordic Exceptionalism by Professor John Pratt and Dr Anna Eriksson
Women Exiting Prison: Critical Essays on Gender, Post-Release Support and Survival by Dr Bree Carlton and Dr Marie Segrave
Dr Bree Carlton and Dr Marie Segrave’s forthcoming book, Women Exiting Prison: Critical Essays on … Continue reading Women Exiting Prison: Critical Essays on Gender, Post-Release Support and Survival by Dr Bree Carlton and Dr Marie Segrave
ANZ Critical Conference Proceedings 2009
ANZ Critical Conference Proceedings 2009 In 2009 Monash Criminology hosted the annual Australia and New … Continue reading ANZ Critical Conference Proceedings 2009
Globalization and Borders Death at the Global Frontier, a book by Leanne Weber and Sharon Pickering.
Two Criminology researchers, Dr Leanne Weber (Senior Research Fellow) and Professor Sharon Pickering, have recently … Continue reading Globalization and Borders Death at the Global Frontier, a book by Leanne Weber and Sharon Pickering.
From Fear to Fraternity
Dr Paddy Rawlinson, Convenor of Criminology, researches in the area of transnational and organised crime in the former Soviet Union and Central and Eastern Europe.
Her book From Fear to Fraternity: A Russian Tale of Crime, Economy and Modernity was published by Pluto Press in 2010.